Honestly, this is the best pizza on the island right now. No discussion.
Aruba Loves You Pizzabar just opened at the end of Main Street and already makes most other pizza places on the island look weak. Small corner spot, indoor and outdoor tables, charming owners, real Neapolitan oven, and fresh ingredients. Nothing complicated. Just really, really good pizza.
The dough is soft, the crust perfect, the tomato sauce actually tastes fresh, and everything feels homemade instead of mass produced. You can tell immediately that the people behind this place actually care about pizza.